United Business Media EE Times




Search

HOMELATEST NEWSSEMICONDUCTORSMOST POPULARMARKET INTELLIGENCE UNITFORUMSDESIGNNEW PRODUCTSCAREERSBLOGSCONTACTEVENTSSIGN UP!RSS

 

Cadence to seek huge damages, Apollo injunction








EE Times


SAN JOSE, Calif. — Avanti Corp. executives may have put an end to their long-running criminal case by pleading no contest to an assortment of charges Tuesday (May 22), but the company's financial woes may just be beginning. Cadence Design Systems Inc. will seek hundreds of millions of dollars in restitution and will seek a permanent injunction against Avanti's flagship Apollo product, according to Smith McKeithen, Cadence vice president and general counsel.

In the criminal case, a June 4 hearing has been set to determine how much Avanti should pay Cadence for losses it may have suffered as a result of Avanti's now acknowledged misappropriation of Cadence source code. While coming up with an amount is not a simple matter, McKeithen said he expects it to be in the "hundreds of millions of dollars."

Additionally, once the criminal case is completed, Cadence's long-delayed civil case against Avanti will commence. Here, McKeithen said, Cadence may be seeking more than a billion dollars in exemplary, or punitive, damages over and above direct damages. And he said that Cadence will "absolutely" seek a permanent injunction against the Apollo placement and routing system, on the grounds that it contains Cadence trade secrets.

McKeithen acknowledged, however, that the civil case will "easily" go into the next year and could last even longer. By then, Avanti may well have replaced Apollo installations with its next-generation Astro product, announced earlier this year.

Meanwhile, McKeithen said, Cadence is pleased with the outcome of the criminal trial — even though Gerry Hsu, Avanti president and chief executive officer, escaped a prison sentence. "We view this as an excellent outcome for the people," McKeithen said. "The fine assessed against Avanti was the maximum allowable by statute, and these are felony counts."

McKeithen said that Cadence had no direct involvement in the criminal case or in the apparent plea bargaining that resulted in the no-contest pleas.

McKeithen said the court will be treading "uncharted ground" when it tries to determine how much restitution is due Cadence. "In a normal criminal case, if someone steals a car, you look at the Blue Book value for it. It's fairly straightforward. But here, we need to understand from the judge what he wants presented."

A figure in the hundreds of millions, McKeithen said, is justified, "if you look at our economic downside as a result of their theft of our code and trade secrets." Cadence was expecting to ask for a similar figure in direct damages in its civil case.

Julius Finkelstein, deputy district attorney for Santa Clara County, said that court-ordered restitution for Cadence's lost profits could be very large. But, he said, "they couldn't recover twice, so it would be an offset for anything they got in the civil case. You only get damages once."

"As a practical matter I assume that if the amount of damages were large enough, it might not be in Cadence's economic interest to continue to pursue the civil case," Finkelstein said.

Indeed, some analysts have speculated that a large enough judgment could cripple or bankrupt Avanti. But as of now, Cadence is planning to renew the civil case.

The civil case has basically been on hold because defendants, who were also facing criminal charges, invoked the Fifth Amendment, which protects defendants from self-incrimination. Once restitution and sentencing are out of the way, McKeithen said, Cadence can get the civil case going again and "start to take discovery" about alleged source-code and trade secret theft.

"We'll begin to discover, with a lot of granularity, if people tell the truth about what occurred," he said. "Then we'll put together our case based on copyright infringement and trade secret theft."

Courts have already determined that ArcCell and Aquarius violated Cadence copyrights through literal copying of source code. What's going to be tougher to prove is theft of Cadence "trade secrets," which Avanti claims includes algorithms available in the public domain.

"My belief is that direct lines of code have probably been stripped out by now. But my belief is that our trade secrets are still in Avanti products," McKeithen said. This includes, he said, Cadence's DSO (Design Size Optimization) technology and some of its routing algorithms.

Thus, McKeithen said, Cadence expects to go before a jury and ask for a permanent injunction against Apollo. Previous injunctions against Avanti products have been temporary.

At present, an out-of-court settlement seems unlikely. "It's an open secret that the judge ordered mediation a couple of years ago. We all went off-site and were polite, but nothing came of it," McKeithen said.

Michael Santarini contributed to this story.











  Free Subscription to EE Times
First Name Last Name
Company Name Title
Email address
  Click here for your Free Subscription to EETimes Europe
 
CAREER CENTER
Ready for a change?
SEARCH JOBS
SPONSOR

RECENT JOB POSTINGS
CAREER NEWS
10 Search Engines You Don't Know About
Go beyond Google and get vertical. These specialized search sites will help you find the business information you need -- fast.

For more great jobs, career related news, features and services, please visit EETimes' Career Center.



All White Papers »   


  Around Silicon Strategies

Challenges for 22-nm node: A team of expert analysts from Semiconductor Insights--Xu Chang, Vu Ho, Ramesh Kuchibhatla and Don Scansen--came up with a list of top challenges for the 22-nm node. Here's a list of 15 challenges (and more). More...

10 fab technologies on the hot seat: There's trouble brewing in chip-making paradise. Delivery of chips at 32-nm and beyond won't be a cool breeze. EE Times has constructed the following list of 10 fab technologies that could make or break future IC scaling. More...

6 fab technologies on the bubble: It isn't going to be a slam-dunk to deliver chips at 32-nm and beyond. See our story about 10 fab technologies on the hot seat. Then read this article: 6 technologies on the bubble. More...

Top 20 chip suppliers: Six of the top 10 IC companies are expected to suffer revenue declines in 2008, with the broader industry hamstrung by a ''disastrous'' year for the memory chip segment, according to iSuppli's preliminary rankings of the top 20 chip suppliers. More...

We want change!: More calls for a change in engineering education surfaced at the recent International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM). Change is needed to become more competitive. Also see the stream of letters on the subject. More...

Hot technologies to watch for in 2009: Every technologist, marketer, industry analyst and reporter on a hunt for the next big thing is bracing for the 2009 Consumer Electronics Show scheduled less than a month away. More...

Top 20 predictions for semis in 2009: To help sort out the confusion in the market, EE Times has released its own chip forecasts--and other predictions--for 2009. So, what will happen in analog, FPGAs, foundry, memory, MPUs and other sectors? More...

Silicon 60 version 7.0 The EE Times 60 Emerging Startups list, first published in April 2004, has been updated to version 7.0 to reflect the latest corporate, commercial, technology and market conditions. More...

 

FEATURED TOPIC



ADDITIONAL TOPICS












Home | About | Editorial Calendar | Feedback | Subscriptions | Newsletter | Media Kit | Contact | Reprints|  RSS|   Digital|  Mobile
Network Websites
International
Network Features




All materials on this site Copyright © 2009 TechInsights, a Division of United Business Media LLC All rights reserved.
Privacy Statement | Your California Privacy Rights | Terms of Service | About